He can load the photo library in iphoto to do the simpler things he likes to do. So far in using lightroom i love the control i am getting with tweaking my photos. Whether youre a casual smartphone shooter or a professional using an slr. Photoshop is for image manipulation and more drastic editing, as well as graphic design. Lightroom 3 will bring several significant changes. I wrote an aperture to lightroom migration guide for one of my other sites called aperture vs. Lightroom best comparisons im tracking and summarizing the best comparisons out there. Aber andere programme sind kostenlos oder in bestimmten. Going to download the free trial today, if it does what it says on the tin i will be very happy indeed. Support in this case, the reader is torn between lightroom and aperture. And like lightroom, aperture is totally nondestructive. You may want one of those instead as youre a prosumer.
Its natural for folks to want to take sides, and pick one program over the other. Adobe photoshop vs aperture vs lightroom macrumors forums. These days, with so many digital photos and videos on our computers, the task of. To a certain extent you are correct in your assessment of photoshop vs. Not only the service let you organize and manage all your photos but it also allowed users to perform some basic photo editing. Its equally unlikley that most people will be able to effectively use both products, which supports the need to choose one. You only need to connect to the internet once every 99 days to validate your membership. P2lr is a free plugin for adobe lightroom that helps you transfer your picasa data into lightroom. Im currently using photoshop lightroom and have been for a couple of years now. I made the switch from aperture to photos jeff geerling. Of the two, aperture s plus is its ilife integration.
Lightroom is a fantastic photo management and raw processing software, but if he needs to do any pixel level work, cloning, masking, layers, type, etc, etc then hell have to have either. Elements vs lightroom vs aperture singletrack magazine. Those who take digital photography seriously need the right software to import, organize, correct. However, if youre used to the adobe suite of products, including photoshop, then lightroom might be more intuitive. I must admit, i found such requests to be a little strange, because i believe both of these programs to be very different. By importing your photos into lightroom and running p2lr, you can preserve all your picasa albums, star ratings, face recognition information, captions, and tags. Basically, aperture and lightroom never make changes to your original images, but store the steps made to achieve the changes. Apr 12, 2020 if you are wondering about differences between elements and lightroom, see our photoshop elements vs lightroom article. May 25, 2011 to a certain extent you are correct in your assessment of photoshop vs. Use 1 of these photo managers if you care about your photo. I think it is time to discover what the major differences are, whether the upgrade suits you, and i will even share my opinion at the end. Its a novel program that doesnt suit my needs anymore. Oct 30, 2016 i also want to switch from aperture to photos.
Adobe lightroom gives users the option to create photo books directly. If youre looking for a new photo management solution, adobe lightroom is your only option. After downloading the plugin, read the instructions page for installation and usage instructions. The lightroom allows you to import the photographs from a memory card and then you could apply the necessary edits. Last year john was kind enough to post an entry on his blog about how aperture and lightroom were faring in the pro community. Feb 22, 2008 but now apple is back in the game with aperture 2. I dont care about this much and have long suspected that when this is turned on that it greatly slows down picasa. Aperture surpasses lightroom in several areas, but dont count adobe out. In the adobe lightroom vs picasa debate, it is important to recognize that each platform has a different purpose. Easytouse tools like sliders and presets let you create photos that look just the way you.
Two top programs that are considered for digital media management today are adobe lightroom and picasa. Apple aperture and lightroom pioneered combining image management with image processing. Googles picasa and adobes lightroom have become the two main. Cant compare picasa to lightroom the two are in different leagues. Aug 22, 20 theres a whole site dedicated just to the topic of aperture vs. Picasa may 8, 2007 i have been using picasa for most of my photos in the last 1. Programs like lightroom and aperture are the more pro versions, where you can do much more serious editing, tagging, processing, etc and automate a lot of actions that might be useful for providing your photos to someone else e. Both do a great job and have similar feature sets comparing version 2 of each. Aperture to lightroom migration guide william beem.
Since apple released aperture 3 a few weeks ago lots of folks are debating the pros and cons of lightroom vs. May 08, 2007 now there is lightroom which has much better raw processing and is basically the same thing. Adobe lightroom vs photoshop vs gimp vs picasa vs iphoto. Im using the same format for the tests and the results, so you can still make comparisons with yesterdays images. Aperture and lightroom function as a digital darkroom and photo library. Both of which are no longer available from apple, and for good reason. Once apple announced that aperture was at its end of life, there really wasnt any further purpose for aperture vs.
Also, picasa has a builtin system of keyword manager. What can aperture or lightroom do that picasa or iphoto. Picasa in reply to nir nussbaum may 27, 2007 i just upgraded to a mac macbook pro, 2 gig ram, 160 gig hd and the software i miss the most is picasa. The new lightroom now excels in that category as well.
I can tell you without a doubt it is far superior to iphoto or aperture. Adobe lightroom cc is probably the best digital image management and editing program on the market right now. Aperture, photos is now the only photo managing application apple is. Before that, there were management apps like imatch or iview mediapro and processing apps like rawshooter and bibble. It seems as if photos my pictures again a raw processing undergoes and thereby the pictures become very green only raw photos, in my case nef files from nikon d800. Lightroom 4 lightroom 4 has been on store shelves for about 8 months now. The best photography workflow, in my opinion, involves both image editing and image management software working handinhand as lightroom and photoshop do. Lightroom alternatives in 2020 david coleman photography.
I shoot canon with 12 mp images, only rarely raw, and my memory of. Apples desktop photo editor gets some nifty effects for ios live. I would suggest that he check out the support out there for the two programs to see how he will be supported in his hopefully long love affair with whatever program he chooses. For those who are using an older apple product, however, there are still certain advantages that can be found in aperture. Just came across this post by accident and so glad i did. Lightroom classic is installed locally on your computer. You are absolutely correct, there are many features which make picasa superior to iphoto. But it is still not as comfortable as picasa, and it lacks a lot of features, such as geotagging. Now there is lightroom which has much better raw processing and is basically the same thing. If you are uploading images from a memory card, both options offer standard prompts to help make the process simple and smooth. The best photography workflow, in my opinion, involves both image editing and image management software working hand. Theyre going to continue refining the plugin and will include it in a future lightroom update and its now included in lightroom 5. Both actually store photos in a browsable folder heiarchy you have to navigate into the aperture library, but its really just folders. If you are an iphoto user looking to move up, then aperture might feel like a more natural transition.
Lightroom 5 so i am currently using aperture and i am very happy with the program but i have seen some of the workings done by lightroom and they looked way better than anything i have ever managed to do in aperture. These days, with so many digital photos and videos on our computers, the task of managing all this digital media has become very complex. So you would run them sidebyside, organizing in one and processing in the other. Instructions how to store your photos inside of iphoto, or outside in folders. The list of photo managers below, are going to be listed more or less, in the order of. Been wanting to migrate to lightroom from aperture for quite some time after a photographer friend showed me the sync capabilities and overall workflow speed compared to aperture.
Apr 27, 2010 aperture surpasses lightroom in several areas, but dont count adobe out. Adobe elements vs lightroom adobe lightroom vs aperture share. Choosing the right software for managing your digital photos is very important because you spend a lot of time with this tool. Apple no longer makes aperture available for download. Aperture and lightroom offer great tools for getting the most out of your raw or jpeg. The difference lies in both targeted user base as well as complexity and overall. There are now several excellent free, opensource photo editors available that are more than a match for adobes products. If you are ready to pay the subscription price, adobe lightroom cc will give you all the features that you need right at your fingertips.
Lightroom is the cloudbased service that gives you everything you need to edit, organize, store, and share your photos across any device. A very quick look and run through of using lightrooms aperture library import function. When you tell picasa to actually save the changes to your pictures it will compress the file size as well, thats why i quit using picasa. Many users find it easier to make quick changes in aperture since you dont have to switch back to the develop module. These keywords can be read by adobe photoshop, lightroom, adobe bridge, digikam, iphoto, and aperture. But it is still not as comfortable as picasa, and it lacks a lot of. Difference between lightroom and photoshop difference. You can also process it in photoshop, though the multi layer is annoying. I can, of course, speak only for myself, but i have moved from dpp to lr because of lrs tool set, the free rotation tool, the digital graduated density filter and the local adjustments brush. So im doing a followup aperture vs lightroom post today. Theres a delightful battle going on between apples aperture and adobes lightroom with the user being the winner. Adobe lightroom is a good generic solution for those who may take digital images with other mobile devices. Theres a whole site dedicated just to the topic of aperture vs.
Prior to the most recent version of lightroom, it was the only one that would allow you to produce books and have them printed. Picasa views all your uploaded files as a library where you. While both aperture and lightroom perform the role of image manager and photo editor admirably, each program has plenty of unique features that set it apart. Sucht ihr einen iphoto download fur windows 7, 8 oder eine andere version, musst ihr euch leider nach. Lightroom at, with regular features on different specific aspects of photo processing in the two applications. And, of course, it works on windows as well as mac os x. And my favourite website about lr is lightroom killer tips. That means you should import the images to your system before you work with those on the photoshop. What are the differences between picasa and lightroom, other. Lightroom is a cloudbased service with three devicebased apps. Im not going to do all four raw converters side by side, im just going to compare it with its chief rival, lightroom.
Photo ninja up until now, i assumed lightroom and aperture were the main options, but im reading that capture one and photo ninja are superior in their raw handling abilities, speed, and image quality at the expense of some features. You dont need an ongoing internet connection to use them. As i worked with the newest version of photos high sierra i had some problems and and asked questions into the apple photo community. I dont have as many photos, but i strongly prefer how iphoto handles the grunt work of file management over picasa. There is also a download button on the instructions page. Picasa in reply to nir nussbaum jul 31, 2008 its worth a look on the first lessons of this tutorial first lessons of each series are free download. The results as published by infotrends, an independent research firm, were conclusive in that lightroom was the application of choice for pro photographers. Many people after five or ten years might have more than 50k or even more than 100k nondestructively edited images in their library. If i open my xtis raw files in picasa it puts a very saturated magenta tone to the entire image as if i shot with a red filter on the lens. Nov 05, 20 so im doing a followup aperture vs lightroom post today. By automatically attaching i files to each file, the software manages pictures with the information interchange model.
So having a good tool is very important for every photographer. Should i store my photo collection in iphoto or elsewhere on. After my photoshop vs photoshop elements article, many of our readers suggested a comparison between photoshop elements pse and lightroom would be more useful. Adobe has just released their first apertureiphoto to lightroom import tool. Some chose to upgrade right away and others chose to wait and see if the upgrade was worth it. Oct 16, 2014 adobe has just released their first apertureiphoto to lightroom import tool. Lightroom is designed more for photography and digital media editing, improvement, and sharing. What are the differences between picasa and lightroom. Lightroom and aperture do a lot of the same things, but the user experience is different. With respect to choosing between aperture vs lightroom, think about which company is going to support you the best longterm. Since p2lr is a lightroom plugin, it runs on both mac and pc anywhere lightroom runs. What can aperture or lightroom do that picasa or iphoto cant.
344 1308 1123 383 146 641 1313 1056 1083 256 446 809 1369 1097 411 1333 165 990 1115 596 185 791 1531 1214 331 1125 324 1038 403 315 1182 995 285 1275 523 181 640 1633 777 925 501 818 387 894 1136 216 1085 1326 69